Order Online

Best Four Cheese Pizza in Winnipeg

(126+ ratings)

A gourmet quattro formaggi like no other in Winnipeg. CrustyCraft Pizza's Four Cheese Pizza layers creamy mozzarella, rich brie, bold gorgonzola and sharp parmesan over a silky alfredo base, then finishes with a drizzle of honey, fresh pear and toasted walnuts on our hand-rolled, 24-hour fermented dough.

Signature Pizza
Vegetarian
Gourmet Favourite
Order Now
Four Cheese Pizza at CrustyCraft Pizza in Winnipeg - Mozzarella, brie, gorgonzola and parmesan on alfredo base with honey, pear and walnuts

About Our Four Cheese Pizza

At CrustyCraft Pizza, our Four Cheese Pizza is a celebration of European cheese craft. Instead of a tomato base, we build it on a creamy alfredo sauce that lets each cheese shine — soft, milky mozzarella, buttery brie, tangy gorgonzola and nutty aged parmesan come together in perfect balance.

What sets it apart is the finishing touch: a delicate drizzle of honey, slices of fresh pear and toasted walnuts. The sweetness plays against the sharp, savoury cheeses for a flavour combination Winnipeg simply hasn't tasted before — all on our light, airy, 24-hour slow-fermented crust.

Why Our Four Cheese Pizza Stands Out

This isn't a standard cheese pizza — it's a carefully composed gourmet experience. The alfredo base, four distinct cheeses and the honey-pear-walnut finish make it a standout for anyone who loves rich, refined flavours. It's a vegetarian favourite that converts even the most devoted meat-lovers.

Perfect Pairings

What Customers Say About Our Four Cheese Pizza

Maria K.
Transcona Local

"The four-cheese pizza was unlike anything I've had in Winnipeg — the brie and honey combination is absolutely incredible. Will definitely be back!"

February 2026
Cheese Devotee
East Winnipeg Foodie

"The honey, pear and walnut finish is genius. Sweet, savoury and creamy all at once. Easily the most interesting pizza in the city."

January 2026
Date Night Regular
Canterbury Park Resident

"We order this every time. The alfredo base instead of tomato makes the cheeses sing. Feels like a gourmet restaurant pizza at a neighbourhood price."

December 2025

Ready to Try Winnipeg's Best Four Cheese Pizza?

Order online for pickup or delivery, or visit us for dine-in at 1311 Day St, Winnipeg.

Visit CrustyCraft Pizza

Address 1311 Day St
Winnipeg, MB R2C 1E1
(Transcona, East Winnipeg on Day Street)
Hours Monday: Closed
Tuesday – Sunday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM